Source Code Review: When You Need One and What It Can Uncover
When should you get a source code review? What to look for in software: security, dependencies, technical debt, and AI-generated code.

Source Code Review: When You Need One and What It Can Uncover
Software can work for months before problems show up when someone tries to change it. Maybe you've taken over a project from another developer, purchased an application and want someone else to maintain it, or built a product with AI tools and aren't sure how reliable the generated code really is.
In situations like these, a source code review can help you understand what's behind the software, which issues actually exist, and what it might take to keep developing it.
When does software code need a closer look?
One common situation is a developer handover. The previous developer is no longer involved, the documentation is incomplete, and whoever takes over has to figure out how everything works. Without a clear understanding of the code, even a seemingly minor change can take a long time or cause problems elsewhere.
The same thing can happen with software that's already in use. A business management system crashes after an update, an application loses data under certain conditions, or a service returns errors with no clear explanation. In these cases, continuing to patch individual issues without understanding their cause can make things worse.
A review can cover almost any kind of software: a website, mobile app, desktop program, business management system, SaaS platform, API, backend, or internal tool. The technologies and specific checks will vary, but the starting question is the same: is the existing code a reliable foundation for further development?
What I look at when reviewing source code
To get started, I need access to the source code, usually through a Git repository or a project archive. Documentation, setup instructions, and access to a test environment are useful too, when available.
The first step is getting familiar with the project. I look at the technologies involved, how the files are organized, and where the main parts of the software are located. In a web application, for example, I'll look at how the frontend communicates with the backend. A desktop program or an internal service will require a different approach.
Then I look at how the main features work. I follow how data is handled and what happens when something goes wrong. If an application lets users create accounts, for instance, it's not enough for the registration form to display a success message. I need to understand how the information is stored, which checks are performed, and what happens when a request is repeated or contains invalid data.
Third-party libraries deserve attention as well. A project may still run while relying on packages that are no longer maintained or versions with known vulnerabilities. Configuration files and dependency lock files help establish what's actually being used.
When possible, I run the software and try its main features. If automated tests are available, I run those too. Static analysis tools can help find recurring issues or sections that need closer inspection. But these tools are only part of the process: a warning needs to be checked, and a clean scan doesn't prove that the code is correct.
Problems a code review can uncover
Sometimes the issue is obvious: a feature doesn't return the expected result, or an operation fails under certain conditions. In other cases, the software appears to work, but reading the code reveals why every change has become difficult.
Some of the things I pay particular attention to include:
- Incomplete security checks. An application might hide a feature from unauthorized users but fail to check permissions when someone calls the API directly. The interface alone doesn't protect the data.
- Unreliable data handling. Saving, editing, and deleting records may not account for every possible situation. In a business system or a platform storing important information, these gaps can have real consequences.
- Problematic dependencies. Outdated or vulnerable libraries can expose a project to security risks and make future updates harder.
- Duplicated logic and hard-to-follow code. When the same operation is handled in different places, fixing one issue can create another. This isn't just about code style: it affects the time and risk involved in making changes.
- Monoliths and unclean code. Everything wired into one lump, confusing names, oversized files, dead code left behind: every change gets slower and riskier, even when the software looks fine on the surface.
- Poor error handling and configuration. Credentials stored directly in source files, sensitive information in logs, or error messages exposing internal details are all worth investigating.
These issues don't all carry the same level of risk. An outdated dependency isn't equivalent to a missing access control check. It's important to understand which problems are actually present and what they could mean for the software.
Software built with AI: does it really work?
It's now possible to build applications, business systems, platforms, and internal tools by describing what you want to an AI assistant. Code-generation tools have made it much faster to create prototypes, even without an in-depth knowledge of a programming language.
The problem is that getting something visible on screen doesn't necessarily mean you've built software that's ready for real use. A screen may work, a registration may go through, and a feature may appear complete, while the code behind it is missing important checks, handles data poorly, or contains sections that have never been properly tested.
The risk increases when development happens through trial and error: asking AI to add a feature, fix an error, and then change another part of the project. After enough iterations, the result can become a collection of patches layered on top of each other, with no consistent structure.
Ranting at the LLM when something breaks does not make you a professional. A professional reads the code, checks the controls, and decides whether the project holds up, can be recovered, or should be rebuilt. The tool is not guilty by default. How it was used, and whether anyone reviewed the result, is.
Some projects can be recovered without replacing much of the existing work. In others, the problems are so widespread that fixing every individual part would take longer than rebuilding the software on a sounder foundation. I don't rule out that possibility when reviewing a project. I'd rather establish how much of it can be reused before recommending work that may not be worth the cost.
Does a source code review make sense for your project?
It makes sense if:
- You've received a project from another developer and want to understand its condition before paying for further changes.
- The software has recurring bugs, problems after updates, or behavior you can't explain.
- You've built an application with AI tools and want to know whether the code is suitable for real use and future development.
It may not be necessary if:
- You need to fix one specific issue that has already been identified.
- The project is small, works properly, and you have no plans to change or extend it.
- You already have up-to-date technical documentation and recent checks that answer the questions you have.
Not every project needs a full audit. Sometimes it's enough to inspect one part of the code. In other cases, the overall structure is where the real problems lie.
What should you get from a technical review?
A useful review should give you practical findings, not just a list of technical terms without explanation. You should know which problems were found, where they are, which ones need attention first, and which can wait.
After the analysis I tell you clearly whether we can keep working on what you already have, or whether it makes more sense to rebuild from scratch (or rebuild only some parts). There is no point promising endless fixes if the foundation does not hold; and there is no point rebuilding everything if the project can still be recovered.
If you have a project you'd like me to review, get in touch: tell me what you've built, what problems you're facing, and what you'd like to do next. Based in Frosinone and Rome; I work remotely across Italy and abroad.

